Dallas Cowboys tight end Jake Ferguson has become one of Dak Prescott’s most dependable targets, but there’s one brutal flaw keeping him outside the NFL’s elite tier: defenders believe they can take the football away from him.

ESPN’s annual tight end rankings, built from feedback supplied by NFL coaches, scouts and executives, placed Ferguson among the honorable mentions rather than inside the top 10. The evaluation wasn’t a dismissal of his ability. In fact, one NFC scout praised Ferguson’s toughness, receiving volume and willingness to battle as a blocker.

READ MORE: Marcus Spears Jr. Shakes Up Texas Longhorns Hoops With Massive Commitment

The concern was much more specific.

When that scout’s team faced Dallas, its defenders entered the game looking to punch the ball out of Ferguson’s hands.

That’s not a minor criticism. It’s a flashing warning light.

Ferguson has fumbled seven times over the past two seasons, including four in 2024 and another three in 2025. He led all NFL tight ends in fumbles during the 2024 season and was tied for the league lead at the position one year later.

Four of those fumbles became turnovers, and the results have been ugly. Dallas lost all four games in which Ferguson lost possession.

That doesn’t make every defeat his fault, but it does illustrate how thin the Cowboys’ margin for error can be. One loose ball can erase a productive drive, swing field position and hand momentum to an opponent. For a team trying to return to the postseason, those mistakes can’t become a yearly habit.

Head coach Brian Schottenheimer previously pointed toward Ferguson’s ball-security technique in traffic. When Ferguson fights for extra yardage, the ball can drift away from his chest and create an opening for defenders. NFL players are too skilled at attacking exposed footballs for that weakness to remain unpunished.

The frustrating part is that Ferguson does nearly everything else well.

READ MORE: Cowboys Pass Rush Gets Vegas Wake-Up Call

He rebounded from a disappointing 2024 campaign by producing 600 receiving yards and a career-high eight touchdowns in 2025. He has reliable hands, runs effectively after the catch and competes hard enough as a blocker to stay on the field in multiple personnel packages.

That’s why the fumbles stand out so dramatically. Ferguson isn’t fighting to prove he belongs in the NFL. He’s fighting to remove the one glaring problem preventing him from joining the position’s upper class.

The Cowboys don’t need Ferguson to stop playing aggressively. His physical style is part of what makes him valuable. They need him to recognize when the extra yard isn’t worth exposing the ball.

Ferguson already has the production, toughness and trust of his quarterback. Until he consistently protects the football, however, opponents will keep attacking the same weakness—and Dallas will keep holding its breath every time he enters traffic.